The Ultimate MasterClass Review (2019): Is The Hype Justified?

Posted 15 Mar 2019, by

Victoria Hughes

MasterClass review 2019: In a nutshell
  • What is it: Masterclass is a brand new approach to online education. Your teachers are global leaders in their field, your video classes have high production values, and you receive genuinely insightful lessons that you can’t get anywhere else.
  • MasterClass Price: Lifetime access to one class for $90 or access to every class for $180 per year.
  • Who’s it for: Those who are interested in an insider look at how art is made and want to be inspired by the greatest minds of our generation.
  • The best part: How candid the instructors are. All the courses are full of super intimate anecdotes that are guaranteed to inspire you.
  • What you need to know: Most of these courses aren’t about concrete skills that you can measure. But that’s okay, because you can learn that stuff elsewhere. It’s about where you get your ideas, and how you use your personal experiences in your work.
  • Verdict: Think of MasterClass as a gym membership or library card; it’s a workout for your mind that’s going to introduce you to new perspectives and expand your horizons.


What would you give to have Serena Williams polish your tennis serve? Or get Gordon Ramsey’s insider tips on the perfect soufflé? Or learn about how Bob Woodward nails the perfect interview?

As a freelance writer and content guru for Global English Editing, I’m constantly on the lookout for ways to improve my writing craft. When I saw that that two of my all-time heroes, Neil Gaiman and Malcolm Gladwell, were teaching courses on writing, I knew I just had to check it out.

MasterClass has been making waves recently thanks to their brand new approach to online education, where every single one of their teachers is a global leader in their field.

The classes all looked fascinating, so I decided to give it a try and report back for anyone else thinking of taking the plunge.

In this MasterClass review, you’ll learn how MasterClass works, my experience taking four MasterClasses, the best things about the platform, and the things that aren’t so good about it.

It’s an honest review by an online education fanatic. While I LOVE learning new things, I also love getting a bang for my buck and making sure my time is well spent.

Let’s find out whether MasterClass delivered on these things for me…

Note: This article contains affiliate links which means we make a small commission if you end up signing up to MasterClass. However, it certainly didn’t stop me from sharing the bad about the platform.

What is MasterClass?

MasterClass was set up in 2015 by entrepreneur David Rogier and inventor Aaron Rasmussen. They thought that there was a huge reserve of knowledge in the heads of experts that was untapped, and that sharing it would, “in a small way, make the world a bit more equal.”

I’m all for equality, especially if it gives me access to genius!

Their aim was to produce classes that have:

  • Teachers who are the absolute best in the world at what they do
  • High production values comparable with Netflix or TED talks
  • Genuinely insightful lessons that you can’t get anywhere else.

Four years later they’ve done everything they said and more, and their staggering list of instructors includes Jodie Foster, Martin Scorsese and Helen Mirren. Gordon Ramsey loves it so much that he’s just added a second course, and this year David Lynch and Natalie Portman are launching classes.

It’s not just famous teachers either; MasterClass have managed to get some pretty famous students to sign up.

The musician Example is taking the Timberland class and apparently loving it. And check out what happened when Steve Martin tried to teach comedy to Stephen Colbert:

The best MasterClass courses for writers

Signing up to MasterClass can be daunting.

Whose class should you take first, and why should you bother paying for information on the writing and publishing industry? Well, where else can you receive the following all in the same place?

  • Learn to grow your skills from the masters of storytelling with exclusive content, such as outlines and readings
  • Expand upon the knowledge you already have on writing and publishing from those who have tackled it firsthand and now want to reveal it all
  • Learn how to encapsulate readers, so they couldn’t possibly put your book down
  • Learn how to manage output and receive the maximum profit for your hard work.

And, not only are there a ton of writers under the Writing category, there are even more under Film and Politics. So, make sure to check out all the different categories, as you might be surprised by what you find.

The following are a great place to start:

The best of the rest

Some of the other amazing MasterClass courses you can take include:

How MasterClass works

This is what my page looked like when I signed up for Helen Mirren’s acting class:

Masterclass review screenshot

Each MasterClass consists of around 20-25 lessons, with videos, workbooks, assignments, and further reading. The lessons all work on a different skill, like worldbuilding for writers or how an actor breaks down a script.

MasterClass Review– Helen Mirren chapter list

They’re structured so that even if you’re a beginner you’ll be able to apply what you’ve learned to your own work right away.

I’m such a bad actor that I was the only kid to get kicked out of the Christmas pageant at school, but after trying a couple of the activities I actually felt a lot more comfortable and confident. Helen Mirren would be proud of me.

Tour the MasterClass website and check out all their classes here.

The videos

I was totally blown away by the production values here, and the amount of work that’s obviously gone into every single video. Take a look at the trailer for Serena’s course below and you’ll see what I mean.

The videos are all between 5 and 20 minutes, so it was pretty easy to fit one in at lunch time or on my commute. Whenever I switched between my laptop and phone it automatically saved my progress.

In the writing courses there’s a lot of talking, but I also got to see the instructors reading aloud, drawing, and illustrating their ideas on paper.

The cooking and chess classes had a lot more practical demonstrations so that I could follow along in my own kitchen at the same time.

Workbooks

The coursebooks are available to download as a PDF and are as beautifully made as the rest of the course. They have a summary of everything that’s said in the videos plus extra references, so you don’t have to take notes as you watch. My writing hand was grateful.

Then there were assignments to put what I’d just learned into practice; everything from research at the library to shopping for ingredients to trying to mimic another writer’s voice.

I way underestimated how hard these were going to be; all of them were practical stuff that got me out of the house and actually learning hands-on.

I will say that some of the homework was a bit weird.

One of Werner Herzog’s assignments involved walking exactly 100 miles from home and documenting everything you see. I like walking but that’s a three-day hike. I skipped that one.

Further Resources

The workbooks and the lessons also included links to a lot of useful resources. I was really impressed that these are much more than just reading material.

For example, Christina Aguilera recommends an app that tests your vocal range and shows you how to use it to measure your progress as you go through the course.

Gordon Ramsey’s class uses an interactive guide to seasonal vegetables; put in your location and the date and it tells you what to buy.

How much does MasterClass cost?

MasterClass has two payment options:

Each course is between 3 and 6 hours of video content, so per hour it’s still cheaper than most college courses, and my local college doesn’t have James Patterson and Christina Aguilera on the staff.

If you know exactly which course you want to take and you’re not interested in anything else, the $90 class will work great for you. I was more interested in playing around and learning something new, so I went for the all-access pass.

The All-Access pass includes every single course offered on the website, plus any that get added in the future. It also gave me access to playlists, a way to explore across different categories and learn specific skills. This feature is massively useful, and I’m going to be coming back to it later in the review.

MasterClass offer a 30-day refund if you’re not completely happy, so I guess they’re pretty confident that you’ll think the MasterClass cost is worth it.

Check out the All-Access pass here.

My experience taking 4 MasterClasses

I decided to take 4 MasterClasses in full, to see what all the hype is about. Here’s what they were like.

Neil Gaiman

Neil Gaiman is many things. He is an author, a journalist, and a blogger, but, once upon a time, he was a failed writer who desperately wanted to fit into the literary world. After years of hard work and learning, he is now listed in the Dictionary of Literary Biography as ‘one of the top ten living post-modern writers.’

And with good reason.

From his groundbreaking series Sandman to his confronting dark, children’s book Coraline, and into his very popular Norse Mythology and American Gods, Neil has created a strong foundation for readers and writers alike.

I’ve been a huge Neil Gaiman fan for years, and with the TV adaptation of Good Omens coming to Amazon in May, I thought this would be the perfect chance to learn at the feet of the master.

To see how good Neil Gaiman’s MasterClass is for yourself, check it out here.

What I learned from Neil’s course:

  • Sources of inspiration. Neil discusses how to get inspired to create, he goes through some techniques to assist with finding fresh ideas when you think you’re stuck, and, most importantly, why you need to build a ‘compost heap’, which is a dumping ground for the quirks, words, and appearances of those around you.
  • Developing character. Step-by-step, Neil walks you through the process he uses to go from a vague idea to a fully formed person walking around inside your head. What kind of physical quirks do they have? How do they talk?
  • Descriptions. How do you make your setting come alive without your audience getting bored? Neil talks about using all five senses to create a vivid mental image and how memorable details can provoke strong feelings. He also shares the most important tip of all: don’t tell the writer how to feel. As he states, “if I leave you crying because I just killed a unicorn, I’m not going to tell you how sad the death of the unicorn was.”
  • Humor. Since everyone needs a laugh sometimes, Neil shares some of the ways he makes his stories funny and surprising, and how you can twist a cliché to make it work for you. And it might not be in the way you assume. Try spotting the cliché’s he uses in his books!

More than anything, I learned that everything involves storytelling, even song lyrics. I’m not going to be writing a bestselling novel any time soon, but does good copywriting and editing also involve storytelling?

Of course.

So does giving a speech or pitching a project or anything that involves holding your audience’s attention. Because storytelling is important in many areas of life, I can’t think of a situation where I won’t use this class.

Malcolm Gladwell

Not many people can write a New York Times Bestseller every single time they publish, but Malcolm Gladwell is 5 for 5.

Is this because he has spent 10,000 hours on the craft? Maybe. The success he has obtained is more likely due to his advanced knowledge of his subject matter. His books are powerhouses in the industry of gaining success. No wonder Time magazine named him one of the most influential people in the world in 2005.

The most interesting bits of Malcolm’s course:

  • Imperfect Puzzles. Malcolm explains how a great work of non-fiction is an unfinished puzzle that allows the reader to put the pieces together themselves, keeping them engaged and entertained with the work.
  • Research. A good idea is the first step to any great piece of writing, and Malcolm shares how research helps him uncover interesting stories, how the best stuff is in the footnotes, and why you should never be afraid to follow your curiosity.
  • Interviewing. In this lesson, Malcolm reveals his secrets to uncovering the subject’s authentic self in an interview, the importance of slowing down, and why you should embrace the unexpected and let go of control.
  • Structuring language. Everyone thinks they can write, but we could all stand to take a lesson from Malcolm Gladwell on the power of simplicity to get your ideas across. I particularly enjoyed his discussions of using punctuation for rhythm and pacing.

I enjoyed his tips on testing his new ideas on friends and family first. First-response readers can show you, on a broader scale, how a larger scale audience will respond.

Malcolm Gladwell’s class had so many practical, actionable tips that I could practically feel my writing improving as I watched each video. Some people claim to have training or knowledge in certain areas or industries, but Malcolm’s success shows that he actually knows what he writes about.

I’m just in awe of this guy.

You can poke around on Malcom Gladwell’s MasterClass page here. I think you’ll find it pretty awesome.

David Baldacci

Writing mysteries and thrillers have never interested me. People say they are the best books to read for learning how to build tension, and they are enjoyable to the last page, so I thought it was about time I saw what all the fuss was about.

David Baldacci went from lawyer to author seemingly overnight. His first novel Absolute Power was a raging success and quickly became a movie directed by Clint Eastwood. With each published novel, Baldacci continues to impress and astound readers and writers alike.

What I learned from David’s course:

  • Inspiration is all around you. David encourages you to visualize stories in everyday actions. How do the people and the things around you connect?
    Outlining. David takes you through how he outlines and provides examples in the course PDF download of outlines he created for his books.
  • Navigating the publishing industry. The traditional publishing industry is competitive. David breaks down how he managed to come to his own agreed publishing terms and relays the pitfalls he experiences within the industry.
  • Writing anticipation. Most novels would be boring without the element of reader-anticipation, it is one of the main things that keeps them reading. David delves into his process line-by-line, scene-by-scene, and chapter-by-chapter.

I also learned that David is a true writer. He would be doing a disservice to himself if he wasn’t racing around after hours to sneak in a written page or two. He doesn’t do this out of necessity for another published book under his belt, he literally cannot stop.

This MasterClass is an asset to every writer, whether they write romance, horror, and anything in-between.

Every line of advice, every word David read from his books and outline, held me until the very end. Throughout the class, I was enamored, and my fingers itched in an attempt to draw me away from the screen to the page.

Check out David Baldacci’s MasterClass here.

Gordon Ramsey

Okay, this class obviously has nothing to do with writing, but what the hey? I love Gordon Ramsay!

I often cook for friends and family, but they always say things like “What are these weird black bits?” and “Did you set off the smoke alarm again?” so I figured I could also do with a lesson or two.

Gordon Ramsay rose to popularity through Hell’s Kitchen, a TV show where he made prominent chefs falter and swore more than a sailor. But his success doesn’t end there, this English-raised restaurateur is also a prolific author and philanthropist.

The stuff I’ll take away from Gordon’s course:

  • Kitchen layout. I’ve been doing it wrong all this time! Now I know store my ingredients properly and rearrange the kitchen to maximize space. I really liked how you don’t need a lot of fancy tools in order to cook well.
  • Knife skills. Gordon explains exactly how to handle the knife so you’re not in danger of losing your fingers, and how to keep your knives properly sharp.
  • Making pasta dough. The way Gordon breaks down the steps makes it seem easy, even though this was something I never thought I’d be able to do. Also, apparently you should never wash your pasta machine.
  • Perfect scrambled eggs. If there was one thing I thought I already knew how to make it’s scrambled eggs, but I was wrong. Gordon breaks down the foolproof technique to making perfect scrambled eggs every time.

I also learned that this guy never met a curse word he didn’t like. I guess Ramsey’s balls-to-the-wall attitude will put some people off, but personally I loved his passion and the way he pushes you to do better.

Everything I made while taking this course got devoured in seconds and I even got a compliment or two. You can’t argue with results!

What impressed me most about my MasterClass

When I sat down and watched the MasterClass courses, it really felt like the instructor was talking directly to me.

The courses are full of intimate anecdotes that allowed me to know who the instructor really is beneath the feathers in their caps, and the one-on-one method of teaching is enthralling.

Christina Aguilera talks about singing the wrong lyrics to the National Anthem at the Super Bowl, and how she came back from that mistake.

Neil Gaiman talks about getting stung by yellowjackets to make sure they wouldn’t attack his kids and how it inspired him to write a story about courage.

Bob Woodward tells the story of going to Libya to interview Colonel Gaddafi.

As a huge fan of all these people, I thought the personal insights alone were worth the money.

It’s really reassuring to know my heroes sometimes have the same doubts and insecurities that I do, and inspiring to see that they got where they are through incredibly hard work.

You won’t find concrete skills in most of these courses, but that’s okay because you can learn that elsewhere. These classes focus on the subjective – where to get ideas and how to use your personal experiences in your work – and that is something you won’t find in traditional courses.

Lots of the instructors emphasize that it’s not about talent, and you shouldn’t be afraid to start with nothing.

Steve Martin says in his introduction: “Know that there’s room for you out there in the world. You don’t have to have a special gift. I had no special gift. Except I loved being on stage and I loved comedy. And that’s all I had.”

It felt like every single one of the instructors got a huge kick out of teaching and was genuinely rooting for me to succeed.

What I wasn’t so keen on in my Masterclass

Before I signed up for MasterClass, I’d heard a rumor that the instructors might answer questions and give you personal feedback. Two lucky people even got to co-write a novel with James Patterson after winning a MasterClass competition.

Did I get anything like that? Not so far.

You can submit questions – either text or uploading a video of yourself – and the instructor will go through and answer some of them.

I’m guessing they get hundreds and hundreds of these things and the chances your question will be answered is pretty small. That’s understandable, but my complaint is that when you sign up you don’t know what kind of interaction you can expect.

At the time of writing, James Patterson had answered about twenty questions, and given general feedback on a bunch of assignments. Gordon Ramsey has answered four questions. Neil Gaiman hasn’t answered anything, although to be fair his course is brand new last month.

Don’t sign up expecting any of this, and treat it like a fun bonus. It’s totally a matter of luck if you’ll get a question answered.

The other major problem I had with MasterClass was the community…

The Masterclass community: Is there value in it?

Good classes aren’t just about the teacher; I also want the chance to meet interesting new people and bounce ideas around with them. I’m not going to lie, MasterClass should be doing a LOT more to make the community welcoming and valuable.

The lesson discussions under each video are about as useful as youtube comments. Don’t bother.

The Hub is a bit better. You can use the Hub to:

  • Post your writing assignments, photographs, or demo tape and get feedback from the other students
  • Get into deep discussions and analysis in the political forums
  • Find practice buddies in the chess and poker forums.

I found the comments on the writing courses really thoughtful and helpful. The other students are people who are serious about improving and they made a huge effort to give me useful feedback. It was like taking part in a really good college seminar.

Some of the other courses, not so much.

Take a look at the Gordon Ramsey community below: it’s nothing but tumbleweed in there. Understandable, since you can’t exactly ask the other students to taste your cooking or critique your tennis backhand.

MasterClass review - Gordon Ramsey communityPro tip: lots of students like to hang out on the MasterClass Facebook page, and I found it a lot easier to follow discussions there than on the MasterClass website. I also got handy updates about office hours and I watched a few on Facebook Live. I definitely recommend checking out the Facebook page once you’ve finished a course.

The best way to use MasterClass

Remember I mentioned playlists earlier?

In my opinion these are the best thing about MasterClass. All-access passholders can watch a bunch of videos from different courses and totally different genres that have been grouped together around a single theme.

If you’ve taken lots of professional courses then you’ll know at some point you start hearing the same thing over and over again.

This is something totally different. It’s taking a radically new approach to learning by pulling information from completely different fields.

One of my favorites was Draft to Draft, which is all about the principals that creative people follow when developing an idea.

Can I learn something about writing and editing from listening to Judd Apatow talking about just vomiting out the first draft or Deadmau5 on how nothing is ever finished? Hell, yes.

Screenshot 13 – draft to draft playlist

Other playlists include how to collaborate effectively, when to throw away the rules, and taking a healthy approach to risk. These are all ideas that are relevant to my career – to any career – and that I could apply to any part of my life and improve it.

And this is the kind of stuff you would never get on a traditional course, where things tend to be narrow and geared to a specific skill.

I learned the most unexpected things from listening to experts in a completely different field. It’s mind-expanding. It’s inspirational.

If you have the all-access pass then make sure you get full value for your money by browsing the playlists.

My verdict: Is Masterclass worth it?

MasterClass is a fantastic resource for those looking to better their craft in the comfort of their own home for a lesser fee than a university course (but no qualification at the end).

The MasterClass price is worth it if you:

  • Want to try something different in a new discipline
  • Are interested in an insider look at how art is made
  • Want to be inspired by the greatest minds of our generation.

However, MasterClass is definitely not worth it if you:

  • Are looking to pick up specific technical skills
  • Want what you learn to be instantly marketable
  • Are thinking of the price in terms of return on investment.

Overall, my experience with MasterClass was overwhelmingly positive. I enjoyed many aspects, especially the teaching style, and learned how to write better fiction and cook delicious food.

I probably won’t go on to emulate their successes anytime soon. However, I definitely think I will be a better writer for having taken these classes.

For me, my MasterClass subscription is more like my gym membership or library card; it’s a workout for my mind that’s going to introduce me to new perspectives and expand my horizons.

Rogier and Rasmussen have mentioned in interviews that they started this project to document the knowledge of great experts to serve as a time capsule after their deaths. That’s pretty heavy stuff, but they’re not wrong.

One day these people will all be gone and this record of their craft – in their own words – will be left for us to learn from.

You can check out the MasterClass homepage here or see if the All Access pass is for you here.

Leave a Reply

avatar
  Subscribe  
Notify of