7 subtle signs of healthy masculinity in a man, says a psychologist

Tara Whitmore by Tara Whitmore | November 22, 2024, 2:52 pm

Have you ever met a man who quietly exudes confidence, respect, and emotional strength without making a big deal about it?

There’s something about his presence that feels calm and steady—like you’re in the company of someone who knows who he is. That’s the essence of healthy masculinity.

It’s not about flexing muscles or projecting dominance; it’s about embodying qualities that make relationships, friendships, and everyday interactions better.

In a world where “masculinity” can feel like a loaded word, healthy masculinity is refreshingly simple. It’s not loud or performative; it’s subtle, yet unmistakable.

Let’s dive into seven signs that reveal when a man is demonstrating the kind of masculinity that’s balanced, supportive, and truly admirable.

1) Emotional intelligence

In the realm of psychology, emotional intelligence is a trait that’s often associated with healthy masculinity.

Men who exhibit emotional intelligence are in touch with their feelings and can express them in a healthy and constructive way. They’re not afraid to show vulnerability or to empathize with the emotions of others.

This trait goes against the outdated stereotype that men should be stoic and unfeeling.  

As the folks at Greenhill Recovery say, “Unhealthy or toxic masculinity may not allow males to fully express themselves and their emotional needs because people may view it as a sign of weakness or vulnerability.”

Unfortunately, this can lead to emotional suppression and mental health issues. 

In contrast, emotionally intelligent men understand that acknowledging and expressing emotions is a strength, not a weakness.

They’re capable of providing emotional support to others and are not embarrassed about seeking help when they need it.

2) Respect for boundaries

In my work as a psychologist, I’ve noticed that a man who respects boundaries is showing a sign of healthy masculinity.

I recall an instance with a friend of mine, John. John and I planned to meet up for a catch-up session after not seeing each other for months. On the day of our meeting, I was swamped with work and needed to reschedule.

John’s response was immediate and understanding, saying, “No problem at all, we can always reschedule. It’s important you get your work done.”

His respect for my time and understanding of my situation was a clear sign of his healthy masculinity. He recognized and respected my boundary without taking it personally or reacting negatively.

Respecting boundaries, be it time, space or emotional boundaries, demonstrates emotional maturity and understanding – key aspects of healthy masculinity.

3) Active listening

Active listening goes beyond just hearing what someone is saying – it’s about understanding and engaging in the conversation.

Men showing healthy masculinity are often excellent active listeners. They don’t just wait for their turn to speak but show genuine interest in what the other person is saying.

This kind of behavior fosters meaningful connections and builds trust. In fact, according to psychology, active listening can even increase feelings of social connection and belongingness.

So, a man who listens – truly listens – is demonstrating a key sign of healthy masculinity.

4) Accountability

Another subtle sign of healthy masculinity is accountability. Men who exhibit healthy masculinity take responsibility for their actions, whether the outcomes are good or bad.

They acknowledge when they’ve made a mistake, apologize sincerely, and more importantly, take steps to avoid repeating those errors.

They don’t resort to blame-shifting or making excuses. Instead, they show courage and maturity by owning up to their shortcomings and growing from their experiences.

Accountability is a trait that builds trust and respect in relationships. It shows that a man is not just aware of his actions but is also willing to correct his course when necessary.

5) Embracing equality

I grew up with a father who believed in equality, not just in words, but in actions.

He treated my mother with the same respect and consideration he extended to everyone else. He never shied away from tasks traditionally assigned to women, whether it was cooking dinner or doing laundry.

This demonstration of equality in my own home has shaped how I view masculinity.

Men who embody healthy masculinity understand and embrace equality. They don’t feel threatened by successful or strong individuals, regardless of their gender.

They celebrate the accomplishments of others and are not bound by traditional gender roles. They believe in sharing responsibilities and are comfortable stepping back to let others lead when appropriate.

As leadership coach John Williams notes, “Healthy masculinity is no threat to feminine empowerment, and ‘real men’ are not afraid of women having power.”

Embracing equality is a sign of confidence and security in one’s masculinity. It shows respect for others and a willingness to challenge societal norms. 

6) Open-mindedness

As you may have gleaned from the point above, healthy masculinity is often characterized by open-mindedness.

Men who have this trait are comfortable with new ideas, different perspectives, and change. They are not rigid in their beliefs or threatened by opinions that differ from their own.

They understand that growth comes from learning and expanding their horizons. This willingness to evolve and adapt is not only a sign of emotional maturity, but also of healthy masculinity.

Being open-minded allows men to build meaningful relationships, appreciate diversity, and contribute positively to conversations and situations.

This trait is a clear sign of a man who is secure in his masculinity and values the richness that diversity brings.

7) Self-care

One of the most vital signs of healthy masculinity is self-care. Men who prioritize their mental, emotional, and physical health are demonstrating a crucial aspect of healthy masculinity.

They understand that taking care of themselves is not a sign of weakness but of strength. It’s the foundation upon which they can support others and lead a fulfilling life.

Self-care can take many forms, from regular exercise and a balanced diet to mindfulness practices and seeking help when needed.

Essentially, it’s about recognizing one’s needs and acknowledging that it’s not just okay, but essential, to tend to them.

Men who practice self-care show they value themselves and their well-being, setting a positive example for those around them.

Final thoughts: It’s about growth

Healthy masculinity isn’t about perfection or sticking to outdated stereotypes—it’s about showing up as a balanced, respectful, and emotionally mature individual.

When these subtle signs are present, they create stronger connections, healthier relationships, and a more supportive environment for everyone involved.

The beauty of healthy masculinity lies in its quiet strength and authenticity. It’s not about being the loudest or the toughest in the room, but about living with integrity and empathy.

Whether you recognize these traits in yourself or in someone else, they’re worth celebrating and cultivating every step of the way.