I make $200k now but still can’t throw away the bread bag clip—here are 8 things poverty wired into me for life

Cole Matheson by Cole Matheson | January 12, 2026, 12:01 pm

You know what’s funny? I could write a $50,000 check tomorrow without breaking a sweat, but I still can’t bring myself to throw away a perfectly good bread bag clip.

Last week, my girlfriend caught me washing out a Ziploc bag for the third time. She laughed and asked if I was trying to save the planet. The truth is simpler and more complicated at the same time. Some habits from growing up without money just don’t leave you, no matter how many zeros end up in your bank account.

I grew up watching my mom work doubles as a nurse just to keep us afloat. Our fancy dinners were Hamburger Helper on Tuesdays and tuna casserole on Fridays. Not because we loved them, but because they stretched.

Now I’m in my thirties, earning more than I ever imagined possible, and I still catch myself doing things that make zero financial sense. But perfect emotional sense.

Here are eight ways poverty rewired my brain that no amount of success has been able to undo.

1. I hoard food like the apocalypse is coming

My freezer looks like I’m preparing for nuclear winter. Three loaves of bread, enough frozen vegetables to feed a small army, and meat bought in bulk because it was on sale.

The rational part of my brain knows I can afford fresh food whenever I want. But there’s this deeper part that remembers empty cupboards and the anxiety of watching the milk run out three days before payday.

I’ve read enough psychology to know this is classic scarcity mindset. When you grow up without consistent access to resources, your brain develops these protective patterns. You stock up when you can because who knows when you’ll have the chance again?

Even now, walking past a good sale feels physically uncomfortable. Like I’m tempting fate by not buying those extra cans of soup.

2. I can’t enjoy expensive things without guilt

Last year, I bought myself a really nice watch. Not crazy expensive, but definitely more than I’d ever spent on something that just tells time. I wore it twice before it went back in the box.

Every time I put it on, I’d hear this voice calculating how many months of groceries it could have bought. How many electric bills. How many tanks of gas.

There’s this weird survivor’s guilt that comes with making it out of poverty. You feel like you’re betraying your past self, or worse, the people still struggling. Like you’ve forgotten where you came from.

The watch sits in my dresser drawer now. Maybe I’ll wear it again someday when the guilt fades. But I’m starting to think it never really does.

3. I fix everything myself (even when I shouldn’t)

My dishwasher started making this grinding noise last month. The old me would have called a repair person immediately. But poverty-brain me spent six hours watching YouTube videos and taking the whole thing apart.

Did I fix it? Sort of. Did it take me an entire Saturday? Absolutely. Would a professional have done it better in an hour? Without question.

But there’s something about paying someone else to do something you might be able to figure out yourself that feels fundamentally wrong. It’s not about the money anymore. It’s about the principle drilled into me from watching my mom fix our broken toaster with a butter knife and pure determination.

That resourcefulness served me well when I lost my entire savings on a failed startup a few years back. While my business school friends would have panicked, I just switched back into survival mode. Rice and beans taste fine when you know they’re temporary.

4. I keep clothes until they literally fall apart

I have t-shirts from college that are more hole than fabric. Socks that have been darned so many times they’re basically new socks made of thread.

My closet is divided into two sections: the nice clothes I bought after “making it” that I rarely wear, and the ancient comfort clothes that I actually live in.

There’s something about throwing away clothing that still has any life left in it that makes me physically uncomfortable. Each worn-out shirt feels like evidence of getting my money’s worth. Proof that I’m not wasteful.

A friend recently asked why I don’t just buy new basics since I can afford them now. How do you explain that the holes are part of the point?

5. I mentally calculate the hourly wage cost of everything

Want to really ruin dining out? Calculate everything in terms of how many hours of work it costs.

This mental math is automatic for me. That $60 dinner? That used to be four hours of work. The $200 shoes? More than a full day’s labor.

Even though my hourly rate has skyrocketed, my brain still defaults to calculating things in minimum wage hours. It’s like having a permanent exchange rate calculator running in the background, converting everything back to struggle currency.

The weird part is, I can drop serious money on investments or business expenses without blinking. But ask me to buy a $15 cocktail and watch me mentally calculate how many hours my mom had to work for that same amount.

6. I eat everything on my plate (always)

Restaurant portions in America are insane, and I know this. I also know that forcing myself to finish every bite isn’t healthy.

But leaving food on a plate feels like a betrayal of every meal we stretched, every leftover we transformed, every time my mom skipped dinner so I could have seconds.

I learned to cook properly at 30, ironically out of financial necessity after my startup crashed. Now I love cooking and could make myself exactly the right amount of food. But I still pile my plate high and finish every bite like someone’s going to take it away.

The clean plate club membership is lifetime, apparently.

7. I keep a secret emergency fund (that I never touch)

Beyond my regular emergency fund, beyond my investments, beyond everything financial advisors recommend, I have a secret stash of cash.

It’s not rational. It’s not earning interest. It’s just there, hidden away like I’m still that kid watching his mom count change for gas money.

This money isn’t for emergencies in the traditional sense. It’s for the feeling of security. For knowing that no matter what happens, I have this backup that nobody knows about. Not the bank, not the IRS, nobody.

Every poor kid grows up with a story about the time someone’s car broke down or the electricity got shut off and there was nothing anyone could do. This hidden money is my protection against those stories.

8. I can’t shake the feeling that it’s all temporary

This is the big one. The success, the money, the stability – part of me is convinced it’s all going to disappear tomorrow.

Every good month feels like luck. Every client renewal feels like a stay of execution. I check my bank balance obsessively, not because I’m worried about overspending, but because I need to confirm it’s still real.

There’s this constant low-level anxiety that I’m one bad decision, one market crash, one anything away from being back where I started. It doesn’t matter that I have skills now, experience, a network. That scared kid who watched his mom juggle bills is still in there, waiting for the other shoe to drop.

Rounding things off

Sometimes I wonder if these quirks make me broken or smart. Maybe both.

The truth is, growing up without money teaches you things that no amount of success can unteach. Some of it’s baggage, sure. But some of it’s wisdom that people who’ve never struggled never quite understand.

I might never throw away that bread bag clip. I might always feel weird about the nice watch. But I also know how to survive on nothing, find joy in simple things, and appreciate stability in a way that only comes from not having it.

These days, I’m trying to find balance. To enjoy what I’ve earned while honoring where I came from. To be grateful for the lessons poverty taught me while working to heal the scars it left.

And if that means my freezer stays overstocked and my Ziploc bags get washed, well, there are worse problems to have.