People who overspend during Christmas often had these 8 experiences growing up

Mia Zhang by Mia Zhang | January 2, 2025, 4:03 am

When folks splurge at Christmas, you might think they’re just generous. When tears start flowing as the credit card bills come in, you know they’re stressed.

Welcome to the basics of holiday overspending.

But dig deeper and it’s not so straightforward.

The reason behind such spending habits can actually be traced back to their childhood experiences.

Some people’s pasts are more telling than others. And that’s because they typically had these 8 specific experiences growing up.

1) Overspending was a holiday tradition

Growing up, were your Christmas celebrations larger than life?

For some, Christmas wasn’t just about a tree, a turkey, and some gifts.

It was about a tree that touched the ceiling, a table groaning under the weight of too much food, and a mountain of presents just waiting to be unwrapped.

If this sounds familiar, then you know what I’m talking about.

In households where overspending during the holidays was the norm, kids often grow up thinking that’s how Christmas should be celebrated.

This ingrained belief can then lead to their own overspending habits once they’re adults, making them believe they need to recreate these grand celebrations every year to truly enjoy the season.

It’s a tricky situation – on one hand, it’s great to relive cherished childhood memories. But on the other, it can mean starting every New Year in debt!

2) Money wasn’t discussed openly

In my family, we had a rule: “kids should be kids”, which basically meant that money matters were adults’ business.

Christmas was like a magical event that just happened, with no indication of the financial cost.

Presents appeared under the tree, delicious food filled the house, and new clothes were bought for the holiday festivities.

As a kid, it felt like Christmas was this wonderful time where money had no limit, and you could have anything you wanted.

But as an adult, this lack of financial awareness during my formative years led me to overspend during Christmas.

I mean, how was I supposed to know that those shiny new toys and sumptuous dinners actually cost money?

Only after a few years of struggling with debt did I realize the importance of budgeting and planning for the holiday season.

But those childhood experiences left a mark, and even now, reigning in my spending during Christmas is still a challenge.

3) Gifts were used as a form of love

In some families, the act of giving and receiving gifts is seen as a direct measure of love. The bigger and more expensive the gift, the more love it represents.

This mindset can often lead to ‘competitive gifting’, where family members try to outdo each other in terms of the size or cost of their presents.

Children who grow up in such environments may associate spending money with expressing affection, leading to a tendency to overspend during Christmas, especially when buying gifts for loved ones.

According to a survey by the National Retail Federation, consumers planned to spend an average of $886 on gifts for family and friends in 2019.

For those who equate love with gifts, that number could be significantly higher.

4) They experienced financial instability

 

Some people who overspend during Christmas might have experienced financial insecurity or even poverty during their childhood.

When you’ve grown up not knowing if there will be enough money for food or rent, let alone presents, the idea of being able to provide a lavish Christmas for your own family can be incredibly appealing.

It’s a way to compensate for the hardships they faced and to ensure their kids don’t have to experience the same difficulties.

But this drive can often lead to overspending, as they strive to create the perfect Christmas no matter the cost.

Ultimately, while it’s done out of love and good intentions, it can also lead to financial stress and debt.

5) They were taught to value material possessions

Growing up, I was often told that the quality of the things you own is a reflection of your success in life.

This belief was reinforced each Christmas, as we unwrapped our presents and compared who got the fanciest toy or the latest gadget.

This belief stuck with me until adulthood, leading me to view Christmas as a time to show my success through the gifts I gave.

It wasn’t just about generosity; it was also about proving my worth.

It took me a while to realize that this mindset was causing me to overspend every holiday season. Once I did, I started working on changing my perspective.

Now, I try to remember that the value of Christmas isn’t measured in material possessions but in the joy and love shared with loved ones.

6) They had frugal parents

You’d think that growing up in a frugal household would make a person more cautious with their spending, right? Well, that’s not always the case.

In fact, some people who grew up with extremely frugal parents might end up overspending during Christmas as adults.

Why? Because they feel the need to overcompensate for the lack of extravagance they experienced as children.

They might see Christmas as their opportunity to enjoy all the things they missed out on in their younger years.

This can lead them to go overboard with their holiday spending, splurging on expensive presents and decorations to make up for the past.

7) They’re trying to keep up with others

Blame it on social media or the age-old issue of keeping up with the Joneses, but some people overspend during Christmas simply because they feel the need to match or surpass what others are doing.

Growing up, they might have felt the sting of not having the latest toys or the most elaborate Christmas decorations compared to their friends or neighbors.

They might go overboard during Christmas to avoid feeling that way again.

While it’s natural to want to fit in and be accepted, it’s important to remember that everyone’s financial situation is different, and overspending to impress others can lead to serious financial strain.

8) They experienced a big change during childhood Christmases

Significant changes during childhood, especially around Christmas, can deeply impact a person’s spending habits as an adult.

This could be anything from moving to a new place, the loss of a loved one, or parents’ divorce.

These experiences can create a longing for stability and familiarity, leading to overspending in an attempt to recreate past Christmases or to make up for what was lost during those turbulent times.

As adults, it’s essential to recognize that the magic of Christmas isn’t found in the amount spent, but in the love and warmth shared with loved ones.

Wrapping it up

If you’ve made it to the end of this article, hopefully, you’ve gained a deeper understanding of why some people overspend during the holiday season.

It’s not just about the glitz and glamour of Christmas, but often rooted in complex childhood experiences.

Remember, Christmas is not a competition or a display of wealth. It’s about sharing love and creating lasting memories with your loved ones.

As renowned author Dale Carnegie once said, “People rarely succeed unless they have fun in what they are doing”.

As we approach the next holiday season, let’s strive to redefine success.

It’s not about outdoing each other in gifts or decorations; it’s about enjoying the festive spirit in a way that doesn’t lead to financial stress.

Because at the end of the day, the greatest gift we can give ourselves is financial peace of mind and the joy of a Christmas well celebrated.