7 ways emotionally unavailable men trick you into thinking they care, according to psychology

Farley Ledgerwood by Farley Ledgerwood | April 25, 2025, 11:45 am

Navigating the dating world can feel like walking through a minefield. One false step and boom! You’re dealing with an emotionally unavailable man who has somehow tricked you into thinking he cares.

But how do they do it? How do these men manage to make it seem like they’re invested, when in reality, they’re as distant as Pluto?

Well, psychology might have some answers for us. It turns out there are seven tell-tale tactics that emotionally unavailable men use to create the illusion of care and commitment.

In this article, we’re going to dive into these seven tricks, so you can spot them early and save yourself a lot of heartache.

Remember, knowledge is power. And in this case, it could be the key to protecting your heart.

1) The classic ‘hot and cold’ behavior

Navigating the dating world is anything but straightforward, especially when you’re dealing with an emotionally unavailable man. One of the common tactics they use to make you believe they care is by displaying ‘hot and cold’ behavior.

This tactic involves a cycle of expressing deep affection one moment, only to become distant and detached the next. It keeps you on your toes, constantly seeking their approval and affection – making you believe they are invested when in reality, they are not.

Psychologist Robert Hare, known for his work on psychopathy, has said, “The problem with many relationships is that we let our hearts run our brains.” This quote hits home in this context.

We often let our emotions cloud our judgment, making us overlook clear signs of emotional unavailability.

By being aware of this ‘hot and cold’ tactic, you can better protect yourself from falling into the trap set by emotionally unavailable men. Remember, consistency is key in any relationship. If someone truly cares, their actions won’t fluctuate like the weather.

2) The master of mixed signals

I’ll never forget the time I dated a man who was a professional at sending mixed signals. One day, he’d be planning our future together, talking about where we’d live and how many kids we’d have.

The next day, he’d avoid any conversation about commitment like the plague. His unpredictable behavior kept me guessing and longing for stability.

This approach is another common tactic used by emotionally unavailable men to create the illusion that they care. By giving you just enough hope of a future together, they keep you hooked without ever having to truly commit themselves.

Famed psychologist Dr. Carl Jung once said, “The meeting of two personalities is like the contact of two chemical substances: if there is any reaction, both are transformed.” In a healthy relationship, this transformation should be positive and mutual.

However, in the case of emotionally unavailable men, they use this transformation to their advantage, influencing you to ignore red flags in hopes of a change that may never come.

Understanding this tactic can help you spot mixed signals early on and recognize them for what they are – a sign of emotional unavailability rather than genuine care or commitment.

3) The art of making you feel special

Ever felt like you were the only person in the room, even when you were surrounded by a crowd? That’s what it was like with him.

He had this uncanny ability to make me feel like I was the most special person in the world, even though his actions showed otherwise.

Emotionally unavailable men often excel at making you feel unique and cherished. They are charming and attentive when they want to be, pouring on the compliments and making grand gestures.

But these actions are often superficial and fleeting, aimed more at maintaining control than expressing genuine affection.

Psychologist Albert Bandura once said, “In order to succeed, people need a sense of self-efficacy, to struggle together with resilience to meet the inevitable obstacles and inequities of life.”

When dealing with emotionally unavailable men, it is crucial to maintain this sense of self-efficacy. It’s important to remember your worth and not let these superficial gestures fool you into thinking they care more than they truly do.

The art of making you feel special is just that – an art. It’s a performance put on by emotionally unavailable men to keep you hooked, even when they’re not truly invested. Recognizing this can help you see through their act and protect your heart.

4) The blame game

Ever found yourself in a situation where you feel like everything is your fault? That’s another tactic emotionally unavailable men often employ.

They are masters at shifting blame and making you feel guilty for issues that are actually a result of their own emotional unavailability.

A study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that people often use blame as a tool to maintain their own self-esteem.

By blaming others, they can avoid confronting their own shortcomings and maintain a positive self-image.

This is exactly what emotionally unavailable men do – they shift the blame onto you, making you feel like you’re the one causing the problems, when in reality, it’s their inability to emotionally engage that is causing strife.

Knowing this trick can help you identify when you’re being unfairly blamed and protect your own self-esteem.

Remember, it takes two to tango. If there’s a problem in the relationship, it’s rarely down to one person alone.

Don’t let yourself be fooled into taking all the responsibility for an emotionally unavailable man’s actions.

5) The selective listener

I still remember when I poured my heart out to him about a personal issue only to realize later he had hardly absorbed a word. He would listen, nod, and even comfort me in the moment.

But when the topic came up later, it was clear he hadn’t really been present.

This is another trick emotionally unavailable men use – they act like they’re listening but they’re really not. They give you enough attention to make you feel heard, but in reality, they’re selective about what they actually take in.

Renowned psychologist Carl Rogers said, “When someone really hears you without passing judgment on you, without trying to take responsibility for you, without trying to mold you, it feels damn good.”

Truly being heard is a fundamental part of any healthy relationship. But with emotionally unavailable men, this listening is often superficial – another way to keep you believing they care.

Recognizing this selective listening can help you understand when your emotional needs aren’t being met and take necessary steps to protect your well-being. After all, everyone deserves to be truly heard in a relationship.

6) The unfulfilled promises

It’s counterintuitive, isn’t it? You’d think that someone who breaks promises all the time would be a clear red flag. Yet, emotionally unavailable men often use this tactic to keep you invested.

They make grand promises, giving you a glimpse of the future you long for. But these promises rarely come to fruition.

Famed psychologist Sigmund Freud once said, “Words have a magical power. They can bring either the greatest happiness or deepest despair.” And that’s what these promises do. They create an illusion of happiness and a future that seems within reach, keeping you hooked even when reality tells a different story.

Recognizing this pattern of unfulfilled promises can help you see the discrepancy between words and actions.

Remember, actions speak louder than words. If his actions aren’t aligning with his promises, it might be time to question his true intentions and emotional availability.

7) The avoidant attachment

Ever been with someone who shies away from getting too close? That’s the hallmark of an emotionally unavailable man – an avoidant attachment style.

They may seem interested but always maintain a certain emotional distance. They’re there, but just out of reach, keeping you yearning for more.

Psychologist John Bowlby, known for his work on attachment theory, said, “What cannot be communicated to the [mother] cannot be communicated to the self.” In other words, if someone can’t communicate their emotions to you, they likely struggle with acknowledging them themselves.

Being aware of this avoidant attachment can help you identify emotional unavailability early on, saving you from unnecessary heartache.

Final reflections

As we’ve journeyed through the labyrinth of emotional unavailability, it’s clear that such behavior is not straightforward.

It’s a complex dance of avoidance and illusion, designed to keep you invested without requiring true emotional investment in return.

The key to navigating this maze is awareness. Understanding these seven tricks can equip you with the insight needed to identify emotionally unavailable men early on, protecting your heart from unnecessary pain.

Remember, a relationship should offer mutual growth and consistent emotional engagement. If you find yourself constantly questioning someone’s care or commitment, it might be time to step back and reassess.

After all, everyone deserves a relationship where they feel truly seen, heard, and cared for. And hopefully, armed with this knowledge, you’re a step closer to finding just that.

Reflect on these insights, apply them in your interactions, and always remember – you deserve genuine care, not manipulative tricks.