8 reasons some people can’t separate genuine love from toxic trouble in their relationships

Isabella Chase by Isabella Chase | November 21, 2025, 3:54 am

Distinguishing genuine love from harmful complications can prove to be a tricky task in relationships.

Many people mistakenly misconstrue harmful behaviors as signs of profound affection. This is quite a conundrum – as they cannot distinguish between a healthy relationship and a toxic one.

The reason for this is a blurry understanding of what constitutes genuine love – and they can often miss signals that should serve as alarm bells about the toxicity in their relationship.

In this piece, we’ll explore the eight reasons why some people find it so challenging to recognize real love from troubling toxicity. Dive in, it might just help bring clarity to your own love life.

1) Lack of self-esteem

Low self-esteem can be a heavy anchor, pulling down a person’s perception of a healthy relationship.

Sadly, those with low self-esteem often allow themselves to stay in toxic relationships. They mistakenly believe they don’t deserve better, or that abusive or harmful patterns are a ‘normal’ part of love.

The fear of being alone can overpower their judgment, and they accept mistreatment as a part of their relationships.

This misunderstanding of what constitutes genuine love is a troubling one. And recognizing this trap is the first step towards escaping from it. The awareness that you are worth more, can trigger the change for healthier and more loving relationships.

Steering clear of such self-deprecating thoughts can help redefine one’s understanding of what true love is, and will eventually lead to healthier choices in their relationships.

2) Personal biases shaped by past experiences

We all carry scars from previous encounters and experiences – and these can shape our perception in our current relationships.

I once found myself in a relationship where it felt like walking on eggshells. The love I believed was there kept me hanging on despite the volatility and inconsistency of my partner’s behavior.

It was only later that I realized I was repeating the pattern from a past relationship – one where I had rationalized the unreasonable behaviors and deemed them a part of being deeply in love.

It took me a while to understand that my past experiences were clouding my judgment about what constituted genuine love. Understanding this was the first step in breaking the cycle and seeking healthier relationships.

Having biases shaped by past experiences is a common obstacle, and acknowledging these biases can truly be an eye-opener.

3) Media’s portrayal of “passionate” love

Almost everywhere we look, from books to movies to songs, we are fed a certain representation of what love looks like. A lot of these narratives glorify the intensity, drama, and occasional strife as indicators of passion in a relationship.

In reality, research has shown that stable, supportive relationships correlate more with long-term happiness than those filled with conflict and intensity. Yet, the media often does not reflect this, leading us to equate love with dysfunction, therefore unable to separate genuine love from toxic trouble.

4) Lack of understanding emotional boundaries

The inability to understand or respect emotional boundaries can blur the line between genuine love and toxic trouble in relationships.

Emotional boundaries are the limits we set in relationships regarding accessing or sharing personal information. A loving relationship must respect these boundaries to maintain a healthy balance.

Not knowing how to set boundaries or holding the belief that boundaries don’t exist in love could lead to control, manipulation, or codependency. Such scenarios can easily be mistaken for intense caring or deep love, further complicating the perception and ability to distinguish genuinely loving relationships from toxic ones.

5) Fear of change

The thought of change may evoke an unsettling feeling – so much that we sometimes find comfort in the familiarity of toxic habits.

In relationships, it’s heartbreaking to watch someone cling to distressing habits under the pretext of love. A fear of change, or the unknown, can lock people into toxic routines, making it hard for them to perceive any difference between this and genuine love.

Embracing change isn’t easy, but initiating these small steps towards betterment can light the path towards healthier, more satisfying relationships that we all deserve. Remember, genuine love should feel like a safe harbor, not stormy, unpredictable seas.

6) The myth of the perfect “soul mate”

Long ago, I held on to a relationship that was clearly not healthy for me. The reason? I believed we were each other’s “soul mates” and was committed to making it work, despite all the clear signs of trouble.

The myth of finding the “perfect soul mate” implies that once you find this person, everything will fall into place, even during tumultuous times. This romanticized notion can make it tough to discern genuine love from toxicity.

This perception can bind people to relationships that are full of strife and discord, under the belief that they’ve found their “one true love”, meanwhile dismissing or downplaying all the red flags indicating toxic behavior. After all, genuine love isn’t about finding a perfect person, but loving an imperfect person perfectly.

7) The sunk cost fallacy

The sunk cost fallacy refers to our tendency to continue an endeavor due to the investment we’ve already made.

In relationships, people often struggle, thinking about the time, effort, and emotions they’ve invested in their partner, making it hard for them to walk away from a toxic relationship.

The truth is, this shouldn’t overshadow one’s happiness and wellbeing. Genuine love shouldn’t feel like an investment gone wrong; it should be fulfilling and nurturing. Realizing and accepting this can create a clear divide between genuine love and toxic trouble in your relationships.

8) Ignorance about what healthy love looks like

One key factor that often hinders the ability to distinguish genuine love from toxic trouble is simply not knowing what a healthy relationship looks like.

Genuine love is about respect, trust, good communication, and genuine affection. It is the sense of comfort, peace, and growth, not the perpetual state of doubt, fear, and pain that characterizes toxic relationships.

When people can grasp and internalize what healthy love should actually feel like, only then can they truly separate genuine love from toxic trouble in their relationships.

Ending thoughts: Love can be redefined

Every individual carries unique experiences and definitions of what love is supposed to look like. However, education and self-awareness play a crucial role in refining these perceptions.

Some might say love is an art; it involves mutual respect, trust, compromise, and understanding. It goes beyond the realm of butterflies in the stomach, evergreen passion, and fairytale endings shown in movies.

When all is said and done, perhaps the most valuable insight is that love need not involve pain or sacrifice to be true or deep. In the words of the renowned psychotherapist, Rollo May – “Healthy love is not necessarily about being inextricably attached to your loved one but finding your own path while walking along with them.”

As complex as relationships might be, let it be underscored that boundaries, self-esteem, understanding, and independence should never be casualties in the pursuit of love.