8 scenarios in life where you should never act on your emotions, according to psychology

Olivia Reid by Olivia Reid | March 24, 2025, 2:37 pm

There’s a widely accepted notion that navigating life should always be driven by how we feel. It’s like we’re all in this giant ocean, tossed about by waves of emotions, and our only compass is how these emotions guide us.

However, as you’ve probably figured out already, following your emotions doesn’t always lead to the best outcomes. And I’m not just talking about those times you’ve sent texts you shouldn’t have or ate an entire tub of ice cream because you were feeling down.

In reality, there are instances in life where acting on your emotions can actually do more harm than good. These are the scenarios when it’s best to take a step back, inhale deeply, and let your logical brain take the wheel.

In this article, I’ll be sharing eight specific situations where giving in to your feelings might not be the best idea. Psychology has a lot to say about this and trust me, it’s fascinating stuff.

1) Making significant life decisions

I’m sure you’ve heard the saying, “Follow your heart.” It’s such a beautiful sentiment, isn’t it? But let’s face it – when you’re making significant life decisions, it might not be the most practical advice.

Deciding on a career path, making financial investments or even choosing a life partner – these aren’t choices to be made lightly. And while emotions will inevitably come into play, relying solely on them can lead to impulsive decisions with long-term consequences.

In these scenarios, it’s crucial to balance our emotions with reason. We need to evaluate all angles, weigh the pros and cons, and sometimes even seek advice from people we trust before making a final decision.

It doesn’t mean ignoring your emotions entirely – they’re an important part of who we are. It just means not letting them cloud our judgment when making decisions that could significantly impact our lives.

2) Responding to criticism

I remember a time when I received some harsh feedback about a project I was leading. My first reaction was anger. I wanted to lash out, defend myself and my work, and maybe even throw in a few choice words.

But I didn’t.

Instead, I took a deep breath and listened. It wasn’t easy, believe me. But psychology tells us that reacting emotionally to criticism often blinds us from seeing the value it might hold.

So, instead of giving into my emotions, I analyzed the feedback objectively. Did it sting? Absolutely. But it also helped me improve, not just the project but also how I handle criticism.

The next time you find yourself on the receiving end of some critique, try to step back from your emotions for a moment and listen. There might just be a golden nugget of truth hidden in there.

3) Dealing with conflicts

Albert Einstein once said, “Peace cannot be kept by force; it can only be achieved by understanding.” It’s a profound statement, particularly when you think about it in the context of conflicts.

Whether it’s a disagreement with your partner, a dispute at work, or even a heated debate with your friends – conflicts are part of our daily lives. And let’s face it, when we’re in the middle of a conflict, our emotions are usually running high.

But here’s where Einstein’s wisdom comes into play. If we let our emotions dictate our reactions during conflicts, we risk escalating the situation and potentially damaging our relationships. Instead, psychology suggests that we should strive for understanding.

This means taking a step back, allowing our emotions to settle, and really trying to understand the other person’s perspective. This approach not only diffuses the tension but also opens the door for constructive dialogue and resolution.

4) Managing stress

Stress, as they say, is a silent killer. It sneaks up on you, slowly escalating until it starts affecting your health, both physically and mentally.

Did you know that according to the American Psychological Association, 77% of people regularly experience physical symptoms caused by stress? Headaches, fatigue, upset stomach – these are all ways our body responds to the pressure we’re under.

And here’s the thing – when we’re stressed, our emotions become more intense. We’re more likely to snap at someone, make rash decisions or even engage in harmful behaviors like overeating or excessive drinking.

Psychology advises us that in times of stress, it’s critical not to act on these heightened emotions. Instead, we should focus on managing our stress levels through healthy coping mechanisms.

This could mean going for a run, practicing yoga or meditation, or even just taking a few minutes out of your day to sit quietly and breathe.

5) Facing failure

Failure is a tough pill to swallow. It’s like a punch in the gut that leaves us winded, sometimes even questioning our self-worth.

And when we fail, it’s natural for our emotions to take center stage. We might feel frustrated, angry, or even despondent. The temptation to react, to let these emotions dictate our next steps, can be incredibly strong.

But here’s the thing: it can be one of life’s greatest teachers if we allow it to be.

Now instead of surrendering to our emotions, we should take a step back and analyze the situation objectively. What went wrong? What could have been done differently? Most importantly, what can we learn from this experience?

So the next time you encounter a setback, remember not to let your emotions take control. Instead, channel them into motivation to improve and succeed.

6) Navigating change

Whether it’s moving to a new city, starting a new job, or even something as simple as changing your daily routine, it can stir up a whirlwind of emotions.

You might feel excited, anxious, or even afraid. And in the midst of these feelings, it’s easy to let our emotions guide our actions.

But here’s where psychology steps in. It suggests that instead of impulsively acting on our emotions during times of change, we should take a moment to reflect and adapt.

This means understanding that it’s natural to feel out of sorts during periods of transition. It also means recognizing that change, while uncomfortable at times, often leads to growth and new opportunities.

Embrace the uncertainty and see where the journey takes you. You might just be surprised by what you discover along the way.

7) Responding to loss

Experiencing loss is one of the most heart-wrenching aspects of life. Whether it’s the end of a relationship, the death of a loved one, or even losing a cherished possession, it can feel like a part of us has been ripped away.

In these moments, our emotions are raw and powerful. We might feel the urge to act out, to express our grief and pain in ways that may not be beneficial in the long run.

Managing our emotions in the face of loss is critical. It’s about acknowledging our feelings without letting them control our actions.

This doesn’t mean suppressing our emotions. Grief is a natural response to loss and it’s important to let ourselves feel it. But it’s just as important not to make major decisions or take drastic actions while we’re in the midst of our grief.

8) Taking care of your mental health

Here it is, the last and probably the most important scenario where we shouldn’t let our emotions dictate our actions: our mental health.

We all have bad days, times when we’re feeling down, anxious, or just out of sorts. These feelings are a part of life, but it’s crucial not to let them dictate our actions, especially when it comes to our mental health.

If we’re feeling low, it might be tempting to isolate ourselves or ignore the problem. But psychology stresses the importance of seeking help during these times.

This could mean reaching out to a trusted friend or family member, scheduling an appointment with a mental health professional, or even joining a support group.

The key is not to let your emotions push you into silence or denial about your mental wellbeing. Taking care of your mental health is vital and nothing to be ashamed of.

Wrapping up

The important thing to remember is that this doesn’t have to be set in stone. With awareness and conscious effort, we can work towards balancing our emotions with reason, especially in scenarios where acting impulsively can do more harm than good.

Start by recognizing these instances when they occur. When you feel your emotions rising, take a moment to pause. Ask yourself, “Is this how I want to react?” or “Would a more measured response serve me better?”

Remember, it’s not about suppressing your emotions but learning how to manage them effectively. And who knows? In the process, you might discover a stronger, more resilient version of yourself.

For a deeper dive into emotional intelligence and its impact on our lives, I highly recommend checking out this resource by the American Psychological Association.

Take these insights, reflect on them, and see how they resonate with your own experiences. Because at the end of the day, it’s all about finding that balance, isn’t it?