8 signs someone is only pretending to like you, according to psychology

Graeme Richards by Graeme Richards | September 3, 2024, 3:30 pm

Navigating social interactions can be tricky. Especially when you’re not sure if someone really likes you or they’re just putting on an act.

Psychology has some interesting insights to offer us in this regard. It turns out, there are tell-tale signs that someone might be pretending to like you.

In this piece, we’ll focus on eight of these signs. These are all based on psychological findings, so they’re more than just gut feelings or hunches.

So, prepare yourself. You’re about to get a crash course in detecting faux friendships and insincere interest. Let’s dive in.

1) They’re not genuinely interested in your life

It’s a common experience – you’re sharing a meaningful story or talking about something you’re passionate about, but the other person seems disinterested or distracted.

This could be a sign that they’re pretending to like you. Genuine interest is a key element of authentic relationships. When someone truly likes you, they’ll show genuine curiosity about your life, your experiences, and your thoughts.

But if they’re just nodding along, not asking follow-up questions or showing genuine engagement, it may mean they’re not as into the friendship as they appear to be.

Psychology suggests that we tend to invest time and effort into understanding those we genuinely like. A lack of interest could therefore be a sign of insincere motives.

Of course, it’s not foolproof. Everyone has off days. But if it’s a consistent trend, then it might be time to re-evaluate that relationship.

2) They’re always too busy for you

Ever had one of those friends who always seems to be too busy? I recall a friend from my college days. We used to hang out a lot and had some great times together. But, over time, I noticed a shift. Every time I’d suggest getting together, there was always an excuse.

“One more deadline to meet, can we rain check?” or “I’m swamped this week, let’s try for next week?” And the next week would turn into the next month, and so on.

According to psychology, if someone is repeatedly too busy for you, it might be a sign that they’re pretending to like you. People make time for those they genuinely care about. Sure, everyone gets busy occasionally but consistently being too occupied may suggest their interest in maintaining a relationship with you isn’t genuine.

It’s important not to jump to conclusions based on one or two instances but if it’s a consistent pattern, it’s worth considering. In my case, it turned out that my ‘friend’ was just keeping me as a backup plan – not cool!

3) Their body language is off

Body language is a powerful form of non-verbal communication that reveals a lot about a person’s feelings and intentions. When someone genuinely likes you, their body language tends to be open and inviting. They might lean in when you speak, make eye contact, and use gestures that indicate interest and engagement.

On the contrary, if someone is not genuinely interested in you, their body language may tell a different story. They might cross their arms, avoid eye contact, or constantly check their phone while you’re talking.

In fact, research shows that up to 93% of communication effectiveness is determined by nonverbal cues. So if their words are saying one thing but their body is saying another, trust the body language. It rarely lies.

4) They never initiate contact

Ever noticed that you’re always the one reaching out, making plans, or initiating conversations? This could be a sign that the other person is not as invested in the relationship as you are.

When someone genuinely likes you, they will make an effort to keep the communication going. They’ll check in on you, ask about your day, and propose plans to meet up. It’s a two-way street.

But if you’re always the one making the effort, it might be a sign they’re just going along for the ride, rather than genuinely enjoying your company.

Remember, a healthy relationship requires effort from both sides. If it feels like you’re pulling all the weight, it might be time to reconsider.

5) They only reach out when they need something

There’s a certain kind of pain that comes from realizing that someone you thought was a friend is only around when they need something. You know the type – they pop up in your messages when they need a favor, advice, or support, but are conspicuously absent at other times.

Genuine friendships are not transactional. They’re built on mutual respect, shared experiences, and a genuine interest in each other’s well-being. People who genuinely like you will reach out just to see how you’re doing, not just when they need something from you.

If your interactions with someone are mostly characterized by them asking for favors, it could be a sign that they’re pretending to like you. Real friends stick around even when they don’t need anything.

6) Their compliments feel shallow

A while back, I had a colleague who was very complimentary. She’d often praise my work or my outfit, but something about those compliments always felt, well, hollow. They were generic, lacking in sincerity and specificity.

Compliments can be a wonderful way to show affection and build connection, but when someone is pretending to like you, their compliments often miss the mark. They might feel forced or generic, lacking the personal touch and sincerity that comes with genuine admiration.

Psychology suggests that we are more specific in our compliments when we truly admire someone. So pay attention to the kind of compliments you receive. If they’re mostly generic and lack depth, it might be a sign that the person offering them isn’t as genuine as they seem.

7) They’re not there when you need them

The true test of a friendship often comes in times of need. When you’re going through a tough time, who sticks around to support you? Who can you really lean on?

If someone is pretending to like you, chances are they won’t be there when you need them. They may be all smiles and fun during the good times, but they disappear when things get hard.

Authentic friends show up for each other, in good times and bad. They offer support, lend a listening ear, and stand by your side when life gets tough.

So if someone is consistently absent during your hard times, it may be a sign that they don’t genuinely care for you. Real friends stick around, even when the going gets tough.

8) You don’t feel secure in the relationship

At the end of the day, the most important sign that someone is pretending to like you might be your own feelings. If you constantly feel insecure or uncertain about where you stand with someone, it could be a sign that their feelings towards you aren’t genuine.

In a healthy, genuine relationship, you feel secure. You know where you stand, and you don’t constantly question the other person’s feelings for you.

Trust your gut. It’s often more perceptive than we give it credit for. If something feels off, it might be because something is off. Listen to your instincts. They are there to protect you.

Final thoughts: Trust your intuition

Human behavior is a complex tapestry, intricately woven with threads of emotion, intention, and underlying psychology. And one of the most powerful tools we have to navigate this tapestry is our intuition.

Your intuition, that gut feeling, is more than just a hunch. It’s your subconscious mind picking up on patterns and cues that your conscious mind may overlook.

And while we’ve explored several signs that someone might be pretending to like you, it’s crucial to remember that every individual and relationship is unique. Signs can be misinterpreted, and people can change.

But if you consistently feel uneasy about someone’s intentions towards you, your intuition might be trying to tell you something.

Remember, genuine relationships are built on mutual respect, authenticity, and shared experiences. If these elements are missing, it might be time to re-evaluate.

After all, as Maya Angelou once said, “When people show you who they are, believe them the first time.”

Trust yourself. Your feelings are valid. And you deserve relationships that are genuine, respectful, and fulfilling.